The PPC Manager's Guide to Using AI Without Compromising Quality
- 4M Digital
- 2 days ago
- 10 min read
AI has shifted from experimental tool to everyday reality in paid advertising.
It's woven into the platforms we work with, driving recommendations, influencing search results, and increasingly shaping how people discover information online. For PPC professionals, this shift brings opportunity, expectation, and let's be frank, some concern.
Some teams are already leveraging AI to streamline workflows and cut down on repetitive tasks. Others feel pressure to adopt it but haven't quite figured out where it fits, what's safe to automate, or where quality checks should sit. And many are discovering that AI, used without proper validation, can produce substandard outputs just as quickly as it can produce useful ones.
Here's the fundamental truth: AI isn't inherently problematic. How we apply it is what matters.
Why PPC Managers Need to Pay Attention Now
The PPC landscape has transformed significantly in recent years. Our responsibilities extend far beyond keyword management, budget allocation, and bid adjustments. Today, we're navigating increasingly automated platforms, interpreting algorithm-driven decisions for stakeholders, and maintaining performance stability in conditions that rarely stay still for long.
Meanwhile, AI Overviews are expanding their presence in search results, with much of that content currently powered by Gemini. This matters because it shapes how users process information, develop search intent, and ultimately reach commercial queries.
The complication? AI delivers information with conviction, regardless of whether that information is accurate, current, or complete. PPC managers now operate in an environment where authoritative-sounding answers aren't necessarily reliable ones, and where critical thinking often outweighs execution speed.
The Real Issue: Unchecked Reliance, Not the Technology
AI doesn't comprehend your specific account structure.
It can't explain why you paused that keyword last quarter, why certain campaigns exist solely for market coverage, or why performance dropped during a particular promotional period. It has no insight into stakeholder dynamics, profit margins, or the ripple effects of seemingly minor adjustments made at critical moments.
AI excels at pattern recognition and producing credible-sounding responses. What it lacks is genuine contextual understanding.
A telling example: Gemini has recently recommended Broad Match Modifier as an effective strategy for advertisers, ignoring the fact that this match type was discontinued years ago. That doesn't make Gemini worthless. It does mean PPC professionals can't treat AI outputs as verified facts.
Think of AI as a starting point, not a final answer. The moment you stop questioning outputs because they sound authoritative is the moment you compromise your quality standards.
"The lure of AI being able to figure out something you can't is understandable. And lots of PPC pros are dumping data into an AI and asking for answers to their questions. I recommend proceeding with extreme caution with the results you get from an AI. Asking AI is not the end of a process in PPC - it is the beginning."
Julie Friedman Bacchini, PPCChat & PPC Mum
Where AI Genuinely Benefits PPC Work
When used thoughtfully, AI can significantly improve a PPC manager's efficiency, particularly at the start of a task, when you're staring at a blank page or trying to structure your approach quickly.
Drafting initial ad variations, converting performance data into stakeholder-friendly summaries, or exploring messaging directions are all areas where AI can save time without compromising quality, provided everything receives human review before it goes anywhere near a live account.
Leading industry publications like Search Engine Land and PPC Hero already use AI in this way: enhancing analysis, accelerating comprehension, and helping practitioners adapt to platform changes, rather than replacing professional judgement.
For PPC managers, AI's value lies in removing obstacles, not eliminating accountability.
"AI's strength in PPC isn't just speed or automation, it's perspective. When you're deep in reports, product details, and performance metrics, it's easy to get too close to the work. AI can help you step back and see things through a client's, customer's, or stakeholder's eyes. That's especially valuable when you work across different industries and clients, constantly switching contexts, like changing shoes and dress codes from one project to the next. At the start of a project, whether you're defining structure, creative, or approach, it helps to have something that reminds you of the 'dress code' for that specific challenge or area. AI can act as a starting point that reorients your thinking to the task in front of you. It doesn't replace judgement or accountability, but it creates the distance that often leads to clearer strategy and better communication."
Veronica Ruiz Morcillo, Seasoned Digital Marketing Manager
Using AI for Ad Copy Without Letting It Turn Everything Beige
AI can be genuinely helpful for ad copy, but only if you feed it the right inputs and treat the output as a draft, not a final.
If you don't provide context, you'll get the usual generic nonsense back. And if you publish that, you'll end up with ads that technically comply but don't persuade anyone.
Ad Copy Development Workflow
Start by gathering context. The better your inputs, the better your outputs:
Landing page headline(s)
Key product benefits (3 - 5)
Primary customer pain point
Customer reviews
Brand voice guidelines
What you're seeing competitors lead with most often
Character limits (RSA, paid social, etc.)
Then use a prompt structure like this:
I need ad copy variations for [product/service] targeting [audience].
Context:
Landing page headline: [insert]
Key product benefits: [list 3–5]
Primary customer pain point: [describe]
Competitor angle we see most: [describe]
Brand voice: [professional/casual/technical/etc.]
Create 5 ad variations that:
Lead with the benefit, not the feature
Include a specific call to action
Differentiate from the competitor angle mentioned
Stay within [character limit] for headlines and [character limit] for descriptions
For each variation, note which angle you're testing (urgency / value / differentiation / social proof / etc.)
Human review checklist (non-negotiable)
Before you use any AI-generated copy, ask yourself:
Does it accurately represent the product or service?
Is it consistent with your brand voice?
Does it comply with platform policies?
Would you be comfortable explaining this claim to a customer?
Does it avoid vague fluff like "unlock", "revolutionise", "game-changing"?
Then test properly. Don't launch everything at once. Put AI-assisted copy up against proven performers and evaluate it like any other creative test.
Using AI for Reporting Without Letting It Make Up the "Why"
AI can help you write clearer reports faster, but it shouldn't be deciding what caused what.
It's great at turning notes into a structured narrative. It's not great at understanding nuances like attribution gaps, tracking issues, sales cycles, or the very real difference between correlation and causation.
Performance Summary Workflow
If you're converting performance into client-facing commentary, try a prompt like this:
Summarise this PPC performance data for a client presentation: [paste key metrics: spend, conversions, CPA, etc.]
Context they care about:
Primary goal: [awareness/leads/sales/etc.]
Budget concerns: [any constraints]
Previous period context: [what changed]
Create a 3-paragraph summary that:
Leads with the business outcome, not the metrics
Explains significant changes with context
Ends with a clear recommendation or next step
Avoid jargon. Write as if explaining to someone who doesn't live in PPC daily.
Then validate: Does this reflect what actually happened? Has anything been oversimplified? Is the recommendation genuinely sound, or just "something to say"?
"OMG Yes. AI platforms are not private, especially if you are using the free version. Be VERY careful in what you share with an AI platform. Do you have nondisclosure agreements and/or confidentiality clauses in your contracts? Uploading client data into an AI will likely violate both. Do you really want to find out the hard way that their data was accessed or used for training by the AI??? If you feel you really must use AI in this way, strip out any identifying data before you dump it into AI. Use the same rules I suggest to my teen when texting people who are not her absolute closest people - don't put anything in writing (or in this case share with an AI) that you would not stand up and share with the entire cafeteria!"
Julie Friedman Bacchini, PPCChat & PPC Mum Said
"AI can be a highly effective tool in reporting when used as a 'translator'. It can turn complex performance data into clear, digestible language for different stakeholders, transforming messy datasets into narratives a CFO, brand team, or product lead can easily understand. Unsure how to clearly explain a drop in Search Impression Share and its impact on CPCs to your CFO? AI can help you articulate that. However, you still need to provide all the relevant context and data so the truth doesn't get lost in 'translation'."
Veronica Ruiz Morcillo, Seasoned Digital Marketing Manager
Competitor Research: Using AI Wisely
Competitor research is one of the easiest places for AI to look helpful while quietly misleading you.
Your research should always begin in the same place: real search results. Search your primary generic terms, note who appears consistently, and review how brands position themselves. That reflects genuine auction dynamics, not guesses.
Once you've got that baseline, AI can help expand your thinking. It can surface indirect competitors, substitute solutions, or emerging players you might not have considered.
Competitor Workflow
Start with manual SERP research. Document who appears for your core 5–10 commercial terms. Then prompt AI like this:
I manage PPC for [company/product]. We operate in [industry] and our core offering is [brief description].
Our direct competitors based on SERP analysis are: [list them].
Please identify:
Additional direct competitors we might have missed
Indirect competitors offering alternative solutions to the same problem
Substitute products/services that fulfil similar customer needs
Emerging players in this space
For each, explain why they compete with us and what customer need they address.
Now comes the non-negotiable part: verification. Validate every suggestion using Google Ads Transparency Center, Meta Ads Library, TikTok Creative Center, and actual SERP presence for relevant terms.
If they're not visible in auctions or ad libraries, they're not influencing performance, regardless of how confidently AI lists them.
Audience Development: AI as a Thinking Partner, Not a Decision Maker
Audience strategy is another area where AI can assist PPC managers, especially on platforms with limited or messy targeting options.
In B2B, job titles rarely map neatly to buying power. AI can help you think more broadly about buying committees, influencers, blockers, and budget holders. But you still need to validate everything against what's actually available in platform targeting, audience sizes, and overlap.
B2B Audience Expansion Workflow
I'm targeting [industry] companies with [size/revenue] selling [solution].
Currently targeting these roles: [list job titles]
Please help me identify:
Additional job titles that typically influence this purchase decision
Departments involved beyond [current departments]
Stakeholders who might champion or block this purchase
Budget holders who may not have obvious job titles
For each role, explain their stake in the decision and typical pain points.
Then validate in LinkedIn Campaign Manager: Are those job titles actually available? Are audience sizes viable? Is there heavy overlap between segments? Can you layer firmographics (company size, industry, seniority) sensibly? Test new segments in isolation before you scale.
Interest-based platforms (TikTok, Meta)
For platforms built around interests and behaviours, AI can help you describe the audience in human terms before you translate it into targeting and creative angles.
I'm advertising [product/service] to [target demographic].
Help me understand this audience by describing:
How they spend time online (platforms, content types, creators)
What problems they discuss in communities
What aspirational content resonates
What entertainment or educational content they engage with
Emotional triggers that influence behaviour
Frame this as a day in their digital life, not as marketing segments.
Then translate that into interest targeting options available in-platform, creative angles aligned to content habits, and messaging that reflects real behaviour.
AI supports the thinking. You still decide the strategy.
Top Tip: While AI can help give you ideas, it doesn't fully reflect what's actually available within the platform. Don't expect this to be a five-minute job.
Common Failure Points
Most AI mistakes in PPC don't come from malicious intent. They come from skipping checks.
Issues emerge when keywords are added without intent validation, when negative keyword lists are applied without reviewing real search queries, when ad copy sounds polished but says nothing, or when platform suggestions are layered on top of AI-generated recommendations without checking whether they even make sense together.
Feed rules, scripts, and automated adjustments carry particular risk when implemented without proper testing. AI makes it easy to generate outputs quickly, but quick outputs without quality validation can waste budget and damage trust.
The Importance of Quality Checks
Before implementing any AI recommendation, you should be able to answer some straightforward questions: does this support the objective, does it reflect real user behaviour, could I confidently defend it to a client, and what happens if it's wrong?
If you can't answer those clearly, the work isn't complete.
Pre-Implementation Quality Checklist
Use this before acting on any AI output to protect campaign quality:
Context Check
Does AI have full context of account history and constraints?
Have I explained why the current structure exists?
Does the suggestion account for client-specific requirements?
Intent Validation
Have I verified this aligns with actual search behaviour?
Does this match user intent at the right funnel stage?
Would a real person search, click, or convert this way?
Risk Assessment
What's the worst-case outcome if this is wrong?
Can I reverse this change quickly if needed?
Have I tested this at a small scale first?
Explainability
Could I explain this decision to a client without mentioning AI?
Do I understand why this should work, not just that AI suggested it?
Would I have made a similar decision without AI input?
Data Quality
Is the AI working from current, accurate information?
Have I cross-referenced against platform data?
Are there known inaccuracies in the source material?
If more than two items fail, the recommendation needs more work before implementation.
Don't let AI's confident tone bypass your standards.
🔹 Final Thoughts
As AI Overviews continue to gain visibility in search, PPC managers need to maintain perspective.
Much of the information shaping these experiences currently originates from Gemini and, as we've already seen, authoritative presentation doesn't always guarantee accuracy. Confident answers can still be incomplete, outdated, or contextually wrong.
That reality makes fundamentals more important, not less.
Understanding intent, protecting brand presence, maintaining clean and reliable data, and applying strategic judgement are still what separate strong PPC managers from average ones. AI can enhance these skills, but it doesn't replace them.
AI won't replace PPC managers.
But skipping quality checks can damage client relationships, credibility, and the performance you're responsible for.
And let's be really clear: if you're not using AI yet, you're not falling behind. Right now, there's a strong narrative that adoption equals progress and hesitation equals failure. In practice, the strongest PPC accounts aren't the ones using the most AI tools, they're the ones with solid foundations and teams who understand why decisions are being made.
AI can enhance good processes. It can't fix weak ones.
If you're choosing to move slowly, test carefully, or wait until your fundamentals are stronger, that isn't resistance, it's responsibility. Used properly, AI creates space to think more strategically, reduce admin, and focus on growth. Used carelessly, it introduces quiet risk that often only becomes visible once things start slipping.
AI should support your work, not rush it.
Stay focused. Stay accountable. And protect the quality of your work.
4M Digital is a paid media consultancy specialising in Google Ads, Microsoft Ads, and Paid Social campaigns. With over 15 years of expertise, we help businesses unlock the full potential of their digital advertising strategies through tailored management, audits, and training.
Comments